Bronzers are one of the great advents in the beauty sphere of all time (if you ask me), but while they can work magic for faking a sunkissed glow, they’re not exactly foolproof—especially when you’re looking for a bronzer for fair skin tones. Not only does bronzer have the potential to help you look like just came back from a tropical vacation with a nice tan, but it can also be used to contour and define your facial features as well. But these benefits are only made possible when you have the right skills, the right formulas, and the right shades to match and flatter your skin shade.

With the wrong shade and wrong undertone of bronzer, you can easily come out looking straight-up orange and artificial rather than glowy and naturally bronzed And, If you have a fair or light skin tone, this is extra important too (and a bit more tricky) to track down, because darker shades—whether a cream, powder, or serum—will show up more drastically on pale skin tones. Fortunately, there are plenty of lighter-hued bronzing products to give even the fairest skin of them all a healthy, natural-looking faux glow. Check out some of our favorite formulas below.